Title: a 1500pts list
Description: criticism wanted
LordKjarl - March 27, 2007 05:00 PM (GMT)
I'm going to play some battles next week and the week after that so thats why I'v started making this list, what do ya think?
Peotre (thane)
-shield
-master rune of spite
-rune of cleaving
->132
Dragon slayer
-master rune of swiftness
-75
Thane
-shield
-rune of snorri spangelhelm
->92
20 warriors
-shields
-full comand
->205
19 Longbeards (Peotre joins this unit)
-shields
-mu and st-bearer
->243
20 Hammerers
-shields
-full comand
->290
10 Thunderers
->140
9 Troll Slayers
->St-bearer
Canon
->90
Organ Gun
->120
(1448)
@ztech - March 27, 2007 05:45 PM (GMT)
Why the Dragon Slayer? Unless you wanted several units of slayers (or unless you needed to slay a Dragon), I don't see the reason. Any points you can spare should be spent for a BSB: I know from experience that a Dwarf unit with BSB is very hard to break, even under a thunderous Bretonnian or Chaos charge. If you take a BSB, put him with the 20 warriors (I don't think Hammerers need him).
The Hammerers are stubborn, aren't they? I'm not sure you need 20 of them. 15 will be quite enough, believe me: they're not so vulnerable.
Why a standard for the Troll Slayers? They're unbreakable, and they're not numerous enough to win combat with their static CR.
LordKjarl - March 27, 2007 05:56 PM (GMT)
I was planning to put the dragon slayer into the unit of slayer so when they get charged the dragon slayer hits first with his mros thats 4 attacks before they hit me, it could make a big difference and there would be a chance i can break them. and thats why there is a banner in there I geuss.
A bsb crossed my mind but it was to expencive, but with the 5 hammerers gone i could make the thane a bsb...
Scaly - March 27, 2007 07:17 PM (GMT)
| QUOTE |
First Blush Comments in Bold in this quote more detail opinions to follow.
Peotre (thane) -shield -master rune of spite -rune of cleaving ->132
Interesting set up a bit expensive at this point total
Dragon slayer -master rune of swiftness -75
Good Idea, I have used it with success myself to protect slayer units, but drop the Rune if you are stretched for points later
Thane -shield -rune of snorri spangelhelm ->92
If you have two thanes in a 1500 point list it one should carry the Battle Standard
20 warriors -shields -full comand ->205
This unit in my opinion is Too small. Dwarf Warrior units in my opinion should be 25 strong to take some shooting punishment and still maintian the ranks CR bonus. Build this unit up to 25 and drop the veteran to get points
19 Longbeards (Peotre joins this unit) -shields -mu and st-bearer ->243
Excellent Unit. I use this unit in every dwarf list I have made in 7th.
20 Hammerers -shields -full comand ->290
Drop one hammerer and put your BSB in here for a LD 9 Subborn reroll unit, very nice a real rock hard unit.
10 Thunderers ->140
Solid unit, though since your list focuses on CC more than shooting be willing to give these up to make your CC game strong.
9 Troll Slayers ->St-bearer
Drop the Standard for points. These should be used as flankers for a larger unit and you only get the standard bearer bonus once so it's redundant.
Cannon ->90
Take the rune of forging or don't take a canon in my opinion. This cannon will often blow up on you whereas a rune of forging cannon is quite reliable. If you aren't willing to spend 125 on this then buy a bolt thrower with an engineer and rune it with a Rune of Penetrating and Rune of Burning (aka a poor man's canon)
Organ Gun ->120
Great
|
Comments in quote. I'd drop some runes in the characters to get some points to make the second thane a BSB and to bump the Warrior unit to 25. I really think this could be a solid list though, maybe even a tourney list.
More detailed these are the changes I would make:
| QUOTE |
Peotre (thane) Shield Great Weapon Rune of Iron Rune of Iron Rune of Stone
Dragon slayer Rune of Speed Rune of Speed
Thane BSB Master Rune of Gromril
25 warriors shields mu and st-bearer
19 Longbeards (Peotre joins this unit) shields mu and st-bearer
19 Hammerers (other Thane joins this unit) shields mu and st-bearer
10 Quarrelers
9 Troll Slayers (Dragonslayer Joins this unit)
Canon Rune of Forging Engineer
Organ Gun
|
Thats what I would do. You could switch out the Canon Engineer to upgrade a Troll Slayer to Giant Slayer if you want. That is a fierce dwarf list I like it.
Tyrion - March 27, 2007 08:23 PM (GMT)
I´m a bit sceptical about those slayers. If I had anything to shoot with, it would certainly be at them first. Really like scalys modifications though :).
Scaly - March 27, 2007 08:30 PM (GMT)
| QUOTE |
| I´m a bit sceptical about those slayers. If I had anything to shoot with, it would certainly be at them first. Really like scalys modifications though. |
The trick to using slayers is the proper deployment (hiding behind a unit of quarrelers which can flee a charge through them without causing a panic check) and yes they are vunerable but they are the only unit you can be happy that they all die (its what they want anyway :P )
Tyrion - March 27, 2007 08:39 PM (GMT)
Yes, but they want a heroic death, not by cowardly arrows. Hills wont stop them from dying ;) .
@ztech - March 27, 2007 09:03 PM (GMT)
Your Thane General should have a great weapon instead of a Rune of Cleaving: it's much less expensive and the loss of speed is not dreadful for a Dwarf. If you're worried about his protection, give him a Rune of Stone.
By the way, what's the Rune of Snorri Spangelhelm?
| QUOTE (Scaly) |
| Drop one hammerer and put your BSB in here for a LD 9 Subborn reroll unit |
Not sure it's worth it. You don't really need a BSB when you're stubborn and have Ld9, it's just too expensive for nothing. The better would be, IMO, to put the BSB in an unit that needs it (like the Warriors) but keep the Hammerers not too far.
And I don't think so many Hammerers are necessary. Being a stubborn elite unit, adding more ranks is pretty expensive and perhaps unneeded.
Scaly - March 27, 2007 09:17 PM (GMT)
| QUOTE |
| Yes, but they want a heroic death, not by cowardly arrows. Hills wont stop them from dying. |
Not everyone gets what they want, ^_^. Shooting and fast units tend to be my first targets for shooting and since any dwarf army worth anything takes a fair ammount of shooting this usually isn't a problem. Unless its a devoted gunline in which case I am glad to have them shoot at slayers since they never panic, better slayers getting wiped out in than numerous panic checks on a 25 strong unit of dwarf warriors. I regularly run a unit of slayers and have had them often pay their points back in spades it just depends on the opponent: gun lines not usually effective, minotaur armies laughably awesome.
| QUOTE |
| By the way, what's the Rune of Snorri Spangelhelm? |
+1 Hit
| QUOTE |
QUOTE (Scaly) Drop one hammerer and put your BSB in here for a LD 9 Subborn reroll unit
Not sure it's worth it. You don't really need a BSB when you're stubborn and have Ld9, it's just too expensive for nothing. The better would be, IMO, to put the BSB in an unit that needs it (like the Warriors) but keep the Hammerers not too far.
And I don't think so many Hammerers are necessary. Being a stubborn elite unit, adding more ranks is pretty expensive and perhaps unneeded.
|
Sure keep the BSB near the other main combat units (Longbeards and Warriors) they should move up as a whole line. Since the Hammerers are the most expensive pointwise I have found that dropping one of them to fit characters leads to more points elsewhere making for a stronger list overall.
LordKjarl - March 28, 2007 08:03 AM (GMT)
I've changed some stuff. I was thinking of changing the Thunderers into Querelers. With thse points i can give the cc untis champions or equip my dragon slayer
Peotre (thane)
-shield
-great weapon
-rune of iron
-rune of iron
->101
Dragon slayer
->50
Thane (bsb)
-master rune of gromril
->115
25 warriors
-shields
-mu and st-bearer
->240
19 Longbeards (Peotre joins this unit)
-shields
-mu and st-bearer
->243
19 Hammerers (bsb joines this unit)
-shields
-St-bearer and mu
->265
10 Thunderers
->140
9 Troll Slayers (Dragon slayer joines this unit)
->99
Canon
-rune of forging
->125
Organ Gun
->120
1498 pts
Scaly - March 28, 2007 11:47 AM (GMT)
I like it similar to my own 1500 point list with minor changes. I think you should platest this list a further refine it.