View Full Version: Discussion Rules

Hp Book Analysis > Through the Trapped Door > Discussion Rules


Title: Discussion Rules
Description: READ!


Prof. Darlene Baker - August 18, 2003 05:54 AM (GMT)
Just past the trap-door you'll find two types of discussion topics:

OFFICIAL MONTHLY DISCUSSION

and

INSPIRED POSTS OF RELEVANCE


The first are those topics started by me for each monthly extra credit. There I will start the post with a discussion topic about the month's lesson. I maintain the right to steer the conversation to a new topic if I wish.

The points given as extra credit will be based on certain criteria. First, simply making a comment on the topic will award the base points. Points will be added based on the quality of the post. Remember, this is a discussion. Reading what your classmates post and then responding to them will earn you more points. Keeping the conversation flowing, bringing up new points, and offering supporting evidence will earn you a significant number of points for you house. At the end of the month I will write up a conclusion and award special notice to the student with the best input for the month. (Anyone want to come up with a name for this special honor? Or should we just put a silencing charm on them? :D )

The other type of posts can be started by anyone. Have you read a book with an interesting take on the eternal battle between good an evil? Do you have a favorite tv where the main characters suffer the same cliches as The Trio? Does analyzing Harry Potter make those real-life literature classes more endurable? These posts can be related to Harry Potter, the class, the class lessons, or any combination. If I don't think its relevant, I'll just delete it. So don't be afraid to voice your opinion. As long as its not blatant spam, there will be no points deducted.

Nagini Black - September 27, 2003 09:23 AM (GMT)
Professor, up to how many points can a student receive for participating in the monthly discussion?

And a name for our special ickle honor for talking too much... The Special Ickle Inputter? LOL, sorry I'm lost for ideas.

~Nagini~

Prof. Darlene Baker - September 27, 2003 06:14 PM (GMT)
The maximum of extra credit for a month is 30 points, I believe. To let you in on my point-awarding, here's a scale.

5-10: Base points. Saying something relevant to the topic

10-20: Satisfying the discussion. Saying some genuine that shows insight and thought.

20-25: Bettering the dicussion. Satisfying the discussion topic plus commenting on what others have said. You can't have a discussion with yourself. A discussion requires multi-persons involved.

25-29: Doing all of the above and shining in it. You've truly been imaginative and mature in atleast one of your points.





Hosted for free by InvisionFree