I did this last year so I thought I'd go there once more now.
Feel free to fill this out, or add your own categories to it.
Movie of 2004: Sin City
Biggest Surprise of 2004: Serenity
Biggest Disappointment of 2004: Spanglish
Comedy of the Year: Deuce Bigalow European Gigolo
Drama of the Year: In Good Company
Epic of the Year: The Lion, The Witch, and The Wardrobe
Foreign Film of the Year: Memoirs of a Geisha
Action of the Year: Serenity
Actor of 2004: Mark Ruffalo
Actress of 2004: Scarlett Johannsen
Worst Movie of 2004: Bewitched
Best Low Budget Film: Land of the Dead